Local News

Stabosz Comes out on Top in Bitter Legal Feud

(La Porte County, IN) - A long and bitter legal battle between local political opponents is now over.

 

By a 5-0 vote, the Indiana Supreme Court ruled against former La Porte County government attorney Shaw Friedman on his request for a new trial in his defamation of character lawsuit against former La Porte County Auditor Tim Stabosz.

 

The civil lawsuit filed in 2021 resulted in a jury three years later ruling in favor of Stabosz.

 

“When justice prevails, there’s very few things that are a more satisfying feeling,” he said.

 

Stabosz was sued after alleging multiple times during public meetings and on social media that Friedman ran county government by having influence over the decisions of elected officials.  The allegations came when he was auditor and Friedman was lead counsel for county government.

 

The case boiled down to whether Stabosz was viewed as making those allegations recklessly and on purpose to hurt Friedman.

 

Stabosz said there was no malice involved in his statements because he believed them to be accurate.

 

“I said things that I was convinced were true and the jury ultimately believed that everything I said, I said in good faith,” he said.

 

Friedman requested a new trial on claims the judge at trial issued misleading information about the state’s defamation laws to the jury, which could have been swayed to rule in favor of Stabosz as a result.

 

The judge granted Friedman’s request for a new trial.  However, the decision was overturned because it came two days past the 30 day deadline for the judge to rule on the challenge.

 

“Unfortunately, we paid the price for that mistake,” Friedman said.

 

Friedman also pointed to a 2022 ruling by the Indiana Supreme Court that denied a request by Stabosz to have the case thrown out.  The high court judges cited evidence of defamation in ordering the case go to trial.

 

Since then, the case went back and forth between rulings by the Indiana Supreme Court and the Indiana Court of Appeals until the high court on Tuesday issued the final ruling in the case denying Friedman’s request for a new trial.

 

On the positive side, Friedman said the failed attempt to have the case thrown out shows he had enough evidence of malice against Stabosz for the judge to feel there was a better than average chance of him proving his claims at trial and be awarded damages.

 

“The only saving grace from this lengthy legal ordeal was that we made good law back in 2022 with the Indiana Supreme Court’s decision on what it takes for a public figure to survive a motion to dismiss (what is known as an anti-SLAPP motion) in a defamation case.  That precedent is still cited in other defamation cases around the state and will be for many years to come.”

 

Stabosz, though, called the lawsuit frivolous.

 

“We all have the right to criticize public officials.  I’ve been criticized mercilously.  Unless someone is actually saying something that crosses the line, it’s fair game,” he said.

Picks Leaderboard

Make Your Picks
Leaderboard
  1. #1 Marvin Freese 86%
  2. T-2 Burt Bennett 79%
  3. T-2 Deanna Ferguson Schweizer 79%
  4. T-2 Devin McVay 79%
  5. T-2 Joe Moore 79%
  1. #1 Joe Moore 67%
  2. T-2 Burt Bennett 64%
  3. T-2 Mark A Flotow 64%
  4. #4 Rex Carlson 63%
  5. T-5 Brenda Steen 63%
Top five players · 2026 NFL Season
T- indicates a tie.

Think you know football?

Make this week’s picks, challenge the leaders, and see where you rank.

Make Your Picks

Weather Center

High School Scoreboard

Sports Scores

Facebook